The main disadvantages
of wireless networks are:
Low data rate: maximum of 11Mbps compares to 100 Mbps
to computers on cable network. This is particularly affected
by numbers of concurrent users and the type of application.
It is far less suitable for multi-media applications. In reality,
the throughput may be nearer 6 Mbps due to protocol and security
overheads.
Interference: wireless networks can be prone to interference
from other electronic equipment and other radio networks,
especially if poorly installed.
More difficulty to upgrade: the newer 54Mbps wireless
system due out soon will not be compatible with the existing
11Mbps system.
Battery life: fat client laptops have a typical battery
life of two hours. Thin client devices (palmtops, sub notebooks
or electronic tablets) can have battery lives of between five
and eight hours.
Example applications
1700-place
secondary school
The school is on a sprawling campus. It has a cabled network
but the addition of a local wireless network allows it to
bring computers to classrooms (where teaching resources are
available) rather than going to a dedicated IT room. The school
is piloting the network in the modern foreign languages department
with 16 laptops in a serviced trolley, and a printer on top.
This is stored in the local office to be used in any classroom
in the department. If the pilot proves successful the plan
is to have a similar trolley in every department. The school
are finding the system very useful as a supplement to fixed,
cabled PCs which can handle faster data transfers.
210-place primary
school
This is a primary with typical accommodation: a Victorian
main building, a timber framed annex, two mobile classrooms.
A wireless radio network has been installed with three transmitters
(able to reach the mobile classrooms with a booster aerial
at low cost). 16 laptops are kept in a purpose-built cupboard
in the school office (wired up for re-charging) and taken
to classrooms as needed. Infants work on laptops in groups
of five or six, each sharing three laptops, juniors share
them between whole class. The school finds the arrangement
adequate and doesnÕt feel the need for a dedicated IT room.
Installation
Radio access points have a range of about 30m in a school
building but this can vary up to 200m in open space so it
is essential to do a site survey. Metal in the building structure,
including reinforcing in concrete walls and floors and metal
barriers such as permanent metal formwork or foil-faced plasterboard
can cause problems. Radio can, however, penetrate a metal
stud plasterboard partition that is not foil faced.
|
Reception can
be improved by (inexpensive) antennae. Cabling will still
be needed to link access points/base stations and main servers
which will all need power. As portable computers rely on batteries
it is important to provide the facility to recharge the machines.
Purpose-designed cupboards or trolleys (which will need their
own storage space) are available.
Wireless connections can also be made over long distances
such as between schools using directional antennae, microwave
and laser links. It is especially important to have a wireless
network configured by specialists as this can affect system
security (for example from hackers) and performance.
BECTA Technology Briefing Paper Wireless Local Area Networks
(WLANs)Õ - available at www.naace.org
- provides useful guidance and contains a number of references
including on standards and health and safety.
Cabling
Cabling is likely to be needed to some extent in all installations,
particularly for a large number of users and where a number
of multi-media applications are used. The current standard
of cabling for connection to devices is untwisted pair cable
(UTP) category 5E. Backbone cables between servers and main
switches are more likely to be in optic fibre (UTP has a maximum
length of 90m). In this way a high data rate can be provided
on the backbone, currently around 1GBps but likely to increase
to 10GBps in future. There are guidelines on installation
of network cables such as ANSI/TIA/EIA-568B, CENELEC 11801
and CENELEC-EN 50173/4. As cable types may need to be upgraded
in the future, sufficient space in main trunking routes should
be allowed to accommodate future needs.
Guarantees on system installation are essential. The main
testing standards for copper is the permanent link test (TIA-TSB-95
and ISO/IEC-11801-2000). Appropriate testing devices (such
as Fluke or Wirescope) should be used.
Infrastructure
As technology is constantly changing, building infrastructure
should be designed for change. It is important to consider,
for example, trunking routes and the positioning and servicing
of servers. The relevant standard for this is ÔPathways and
SpacesÕ (ANSI/TIA/EIA-569-A).
If file servers are sited in unoccupied rooms the need for
air conditioning may be reduced as the computers themselves
can withstand higher temperatures than people. However there
have been reports of unreliability where several servers are
located in a small space without ventilation. Access will
be required for management on a regular basis and a secure
ICT office is a preferred solution..
|